Generated Prediction

Cellar Dweller Showdown: The Under 5.5 is the Only Logical Move

Event: Tue, Nov 10 · 8:10 PM EST

Published Nov. 10, 2026, 6 p.m. · icehockey_nhl

Two bottom-tier offenses meet in St. Louis, creating a low-scoring stalemate that makes the Under 5.5 the clear value play.

Cellar Dweller Showdown: The Under 5.5 is the Only Logical Move

Watch the breakdown

The Pick

Under 5.5 (+105)

Why It Works

This is a matchup of two teams that have essentially given up on the idea of being good. Detroit and St. Louis are both sitting at 7-8, sharing the same mediocrity like siblings who both failed the same driving test. When two squads are fighting for the same basement spot, the game often devolves into a cautious, low-event grind. Nobody wants to be the first to blink, so the puck stays in the corners while the clock ticks down.

Detroit’s offense is a mystery. They generate 2,316 shots, ranking 11th in the league, but they convert at a dismal 10.3% shooting percentage, ranking 26th. That is a lot of air shots and a very few pucks in the net. It’s like trying to hit a fly with a sledgehammer. St. Louis is even more frustrating. They rank 24th in goals scored and 29th in shots. Their offense is less "inefficient" and more "non-existent." They are generating the fewest chances in the league, which means they are relying on luck or a miracle to score.

Defensively, both teams are mediocre. They are tied for 19th in goals allowed, averaging 3.10 per game. That is not a brick wall; it is a screen door. But when two teams with weak offenses meet two teams with leaky defenses, the result is often a low-scoring affair. The math is simple: if you can’t score, you don’t score. The total of 5.5 feels high for two teams that struggle to find the back of the net.

Odds & Context

The +105 price on the Under offers solid value. The market is likely pricing in the potential for a shootout or a high-variance game, but the underlying numbers tell a different story. Detroit’s low shooting percentage and St. Louis’s lack of shot volume are the key indicators. These are not teams that are going to outplay each other. They are going to outlast each other, or rather, they are going to out-bored each other. The total reflects a game where both teams are trying to avoid losing, not trying to win big.

Risk to Watch

The main risk is a special teams spike. If one team gets a power play goal early, the other team might be forced to pull the goalie, which could open up the game. However, given the quality of both offenses, that seems unlikely. Another risk is a hot shooting stretch. If Detroit suddenly starts converting at a higher rate, the under could be in trouble. But based on current form, that is a low-probability scenario. Stick with the under.

Odd$mith app

📱 Every pick, in your pocket. Daily best-bet cards, live odds, and the full board — free on Android. Get the app →